mmm! i LOVE sugar cookies!

Sugar cookie,but frosting/icing is a must!

Gingerbread!

Sugar cookies are beyond nast. That texture is appalling.

Me love sugar cookies. Haven't had gingerbread since I was little, loved it then, hate it now.

Gingerbread! I'm making a batch this year

I hate gingerbread now. I used to love it.

Sugar cookie. Though I have to eat it with a banana.

never liked ginger bread! when i was little all my cousins and i would make sugar cookies together and then decorate them together--they were UGLAY! but they are still my faveeeee!

Neither, butter cookies for me.

i'll take any kind of cookie, as long as it's not filled with jam.

my aunt makes amazing gingerbread, though. i'll have to ask her for the recipe this year.

I could never choose between the two

Can't choose. Love both of them too much!

I'm not a huge fan of gingerbread. I think it's too spicy for my palate. I do love the soft Amish sugar cookies that my Grandma used to make every year though.

SUGAR!!!!!!!

Gingerbread and I never quite meshed...

Definitely gingerbread, but my mum has made a simplified version since we were little and it's my absolute favourite - and really easy.

Gingerbread Biscuits

Ingredients
225 grams white flour
175 grams fine brown sugar
100 grams butter
1 tsp ground ginger
1 beaten egg

Rub the butter into the flour and ginger. Add the sugar. Make a well in the center of the dry ingredients and add the egg, mixing well. Knead the mixture. Roll out, cut shapes and bake in an oven on medium heat until lightly golden. When cool, frost with melted white chocolate and decorate with lollies.

Yum.

I prefer puffiness or thumb print cookies

Sugar cookies.

One of each but that's it, I prefer soft cookies but you gotta have these during the holidays.

They're both gross imo

I definitely prefer sugar cookies... I never got into gingerbread.

I love both but if I had to choose between the two sugar cookies win it for me.

I love sugar cookies... but gingerbread is delish if it's the soft and chewy soft.

*sort, not soft

Haha, but I guess doubly soft is okay as well.

I like both, although I'm not crazy about store bought cookies, I'd rather have them homemade, that are soft and chewy.

Wild Magelet, your recipe sounds yummy- thanks for sharing it.

Both aren't too bad, but I'd much prefer shortbread cookies!

both please!

I love a good gingerbread man. But I usually bake Snickerdoodle.

i'm more of a sugar cookie fan personally.

I love sugar cookies with icing! Yum!

I enjoy both flavors but the gingerbread cookie must be not too spicy and the sugar cookie must be crisp or very buttery, not overly sweet. Just one of each, though. I can't handle more than that.

I will take choc chip instead.

One of both, but only if they're soft!

We have this recipe for the most amazing sugar cookies that you roll out paper thin and cut them. They melt in your mouth!!!

Amen, Punk Glam Queen.

Butter cookies for me, please!

Honey biscuits for me. My nana used to make mountains of these every year at Christmas time.

I dislike most gingerbread; it's flavor is too strong for me. I love homemade sugar cookies.